Unfulfilled Wishes, Heartfelt Prayers, and
Calm Determination
A Rabbinic Perspective on the War in Iraq
For The Tacoma News Tribune
April 2003
Why are you silent when the wicked devours a person more
righteous than he?
Habakkuk 1:13
Here is what I wish: I wish that Saddam Hussein was a decent,
reasonable human being. I wish that he would cooperate with the
UN, and humbly agree to disarm Iraq completely. I wish that
Saddam would turn into a nice guy, that he would stop torturing
his people, and stop having his goons tear out dissenters’
tongues in public. I wish that he would cease his anti-America,
anti-Israel rhetoric, and promise never to kill us. I wish that
he would live in just one extravagant palace – or maybe
two – sell the others, and use the proceeds to feed and educate
his people.
What’s that you say? I can’t have those things? OK, then all I
wish is that he would sit down and talk with us. If he won’t be
our friend, then I wish he’d simply promise not to harm us. I
wish that he would take a logical look what’s going on around
him, and see the great heights his nation could reach if only he
treated his citizens humanely, and stopped oppressing them.
Then, he could befriend the other nations of the world and bring
vast wealth into his country once again. Then, he could lead a
nation that would be true exemplar of the richness and majesty
of Arab culture. Then, he could feel comfortable sleeping in the
same place two nights in a row.
But wait. I can’t have those things, either? Well, then all I
wish is for the diplomatic means to get him and his regime out
of power – to get them out of power quickly, and in a way that
causes the Iraqi people as little suffering as possible. Of
course, doing so will demand the complete and enthusiastic
cooperation of every nation of the world, so I wish for that, as
well.
But you say that the diplomatic efforts have failed? That many
nations refuse to cooperate? In that case, my only response is
to hope that our national leaders continue their diplomacy,
anyway. In the meantime, in the absence of peaceful means to
protect Iraq and the world against this tyrant, I am left with
no choice but to hope that we as a nation have the fortitude and
courage to take military action.
Sadly, this is a time of wishes unfulfilled and hopes
unrealized. Sadly, we must remember that there are powerful
people in the world who want to destroy us and all that we stand
for. Sadly, Saddam Hussein and his regime have left us but one
option – a military campaign to help ensure a safe tomorrow for
all humanity.
Jewish law says, “If somebody is trying to kill you, you kill
him first.” This should be obvious to us Americans – we have the
right to defend ourselves. Unconditionally. And I cannot fathom
why that principle seems to be in such dispute these days. If a
bully is trying to kill us, we need to fight back. Sure, it
would be nice if the French and others would support our fight
against him; it would be nice if we could guarantee that, when
this bully goes down, an even worse bully won’t take his place;
it would be nice to know that fighting him won’t anger his
buddies. All of those things would be nice, but if we know that
we must fight to defend ourselves, then those other factors are
ultimately irrelevant.
As a Jew, I am called to lead a sacred life. Being sacred
doesn’t mean climbing to a desolate mountaintop or retreating
into a monastic cell, but rather engaging with the world, making
the here and now more Godly in every way we can. Although I can
never be completely certain whether we are doing it right, all
that I have learned about God and God’s wishes lead me to one
terrifying conclusion: The free world must do all it can to
remove Saddam Hussein and his despotic regime from power as
quickly as possible. To do otherwise would be to passively
tolerate evil in a most ungodly manner.
So this is what I pray: I pray for the safety of our soldiers,
and for the safety of the Iraqi people. I pray that Saddam
Hussein is overthrown, so that the world will no longer need to
fear his evil deeds. I pray for a safer, kinder, more humane
world – a world whose leaders are good, kind, and sane. Most of
all, I pray that this conflict will end soon, and that the
soldiers on both sides can return home safely, ours with the
knowledge that they have bravely helped the world take a crucial
step toward making it a better place for all humanity.
[back
to top]
|